Customized Learning Journeys: Benefits of 1-on-1 Instruction vs. Group Classes
by Michael Freeman
When it comes to academic tutoring, students often find themselves at a crossroads: Should they join a group class or go for one-on-one lessons? Group classes bring together several students learning alongside each other under the guidance of an instructor. Meanwhile, one-on-one lessons offer personalized instruction tailored specifically to a student’s unique needs.
Both options aim to support students in achieving their academic goals, but each has its own set of perks that are worth considering. It’s important for students and parents to think about what will work best for their learning style and preferences. Let’s dive into the pros of each approach and see how they cater to different types of learners.
Benefits of Group Classes
Collaboration with Others
A key benefit of group classes is the opportunity for students to interact with their peers in an academic setting. This interaction helps students develop essential skills like teamwork and respectful communication. Working with others also naturally fosters a range of soft skills, such as active listening and providing peer feedback, which are crucial for students of all ages. The best part? These skills often translate seamlessly to school projects long after the group class ends. While more introverted students might need a little time to adjust to the social aspects of group classes, the benefits are well worth the brief learning curve.
Diverse Perspectives
Another advantage of group classes is the exposure to a wide range of perspectives and ideas. When students from different backgrounds share their viewpoints and experiences, it promotes open-mindedness and encourages deeper thinking about the topics being studied. This is particularly valuable in subjects like literature, history, and debate, where understanding and synthesizing multiple viewpoints is crucial. Even for students not focusing on these subjects, embracing new ideas and perspectives can be incredibly beneficial. For instance, those planning to study abroad will gain valuable early exposure to the diversity of perspectives that group classes offer.
Familiar Structure
The structure of an academic setting is something every student needs to learn to navigate sooner rather than later. Group classes, with their set curriculum, predetermined schedules, and lesson plans, naturally help students do just that. Many students find it easier to stay organized and focused in these environments compared to 1-on-1 lessons. This structured approach is often the best fit for younger learners who benefit from a “road map” that offers predictability and assurance. It’s common for students new to academic tutoring to start with group classes before transitioning to direct instruction in a 1-on-1 setting.
Varied Resources
Group classes also come with the added benefit of an expanded set of resources. For instance, students in science group classes may have access to multiple labs where they can perform experiments with their classmates. Similarly, coding or tech-focused group classes allow students to build custom games, construct robots, and create digital designs using proprietary software. Even in humanities classes, students can explore a wide variety of texts and content forms through an enriched curriculum. These kinds of resources aren’t always available in 1-on-1 learning environments, making group classes particularly appealing for students who thrive on “hands-on” experiences.
External Motivation
The competitive but friendly atmosphere of group classes is another compelling reason why students enroll, especially during summer or winter breaks. This environment often leads to “positive peer pressure”—seeing friends and classmates working hard can be a huge motivator to push oneself further. Instead of relying solely on self-motivation, students can join group classes with friends who share similar goals, like scoring a 5 on an AP exam, improving SAT scores, or getting a head start on essay writing skills. The opportunity for extrinsic motivation is a big draw for many students in group classes
Benefits of 1-on-1 Lessons
Personalized Instruction
One of the biggest benefits of 1-on-1 tutoring is the personalized attention you get. Unlike group classes, a private tutor can tailor lessons specifically to your learning style and strengths, and focus on the areas you need to improve. Tutors can adjust their teaching methods to match your pace and give you targeted feedback, ensuring you get the support you need to truly master the subject. If you’re looking to get ahead (or catch up) quickly, 1-on-1 tutoring is often the way to go.
Full Attention and Immediate Feedback
In a group class, it’s tough for tutors to give each student their undivided attention all the time. With 1-on-1 tutoring, you get the tutor’s full focus, which means you receive immediate feedback and clarification whenever you need it. This close monitoring allows the tutor to adjust lessons on the fly, addressing any challenges you’re facing right away. For example, a math tutor might spend extra time helping you master polynomial expressions, while a history tutor could focus on refining your essay-writing strategies for exams like the APUSH. This personalized approach ensures you’re always getting the most out of each session.
Flexible Scheduling
One of the biggest perks of 1-on-1 tutoring is the flexibility it offers for scheduling. Whether you have a busy timetable or need to adjust your sessions around other commitments, private tutoring can adapt to fit your needs. Regular practice is key to making progress, and with 1-on-1 tutoring, you can maintain a consistent study routine no matter what’s going on in your life. Plus, if you have an important test coming up or a big project to work on, you can easily extend a lesson or add extra sessions to get the help you need. Group classes, on the other hand, often have fixed schedules that might not always align with your availability.
Customized Learning Materials
In a 1-on-1 setting, tutors can create and use learning materials that are specifically designed for you. This makes studying more relevant and engaging because the content matches your interests and needs. For instance, if you’re working on a world history project, your tutor can choose primary sources that you find fascinating. While group classes offer a variety of materials, they can’t be as easily customized to each student. If you thrive on hands-on learning, the ability to use tailored resources in 1-on-1 tutoring can make a big difference in how much you enjoy and retain the material.
Improved Self-Confidence
Group classes can sometimes feel intimidating, especially when it comes to participating in discussions or answering questions in front of others. This can hold some students back from building their confidence. In a 1-on-1 tutoring environment, you have a safe space to ask questions and make mistakes without feeling judged. This supportive setting helps you build self-confidence as you become more comfortable with the material and your abilities. Plus, as your confidence grows through private sessions, you might find it easier to participate in larger group settings as well.
What should international school students do next?
For international school students, it’s important to know that no matter where you are on your academic journey, there is a strategic course of action available to help you achieve your admissions goals. Tokyo Academics has over 10 years of experience helping students get the grades, test scores, essays, and other factors needed to gain admission to top schools around the world. Connect with us today to see how we can help you get into the boarding schools and colleges of your dreams!
Looking for More International School Guidance?
Visit our Resource Center and gain access to recorded webinars, podcast episodes, school profiles, and more.